Disneyland vs Disney World Ride Comparisons

Read about the ultimate Disneyland vs Disney World ride comparisons.  Which has better rides, Disneyland vs Disney World?

Introduction

My family and I live in South Louisiana.  My wife and I both grew up going to Disney World because it is simply closer.

In 2012, my wife and I briefly visited Disneyland in California during one of my business trips.  We really enjoyed our time there and vowed to come back with our children.

And, we kept our promise and visited Disneyland in 2017 with our children.

Which park has better rides?  This is a very common question I get asked quite often from friends and family.

Therefore, I decided to do a ride comparison of our favorite similar attractions:  Disneyland vs. Disney World: Ride Comparisons.

So, Lets get ready to rumble…

 

California Screamin’ vs. Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster

Disneyland-vs-Disneyworld-Ride-Comparisons-California-Screamin

Winner:  Disneyland, California Screamin

Obviously, California Screamin and Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster are both high-speed roller coasters.

It is located in Disneyland’s California Adventure and Disney World’s Hollywood Studios houses Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster.

Why is California Screamin better than Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster?  

Length of ride, visibility, and wait times.

The length of the California Screamin ride is much longer than Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster.

Also, California Screamin is outside, so visibility is awesome.  Furthermore, I like to see what is ahead – sort of adds to the excitement.

And, wait times seem much shorter at California Screamin than Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster.

These 2 roller coasters are similar in many aspects such as they both launch to a countdown at the beginning and they both go in a loop.

California Screamin is longer and has 1 loop compared to 1 loop and 2 inversions on Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster.  

However, Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster seems faster, but this could be an illusion because it’s in the dark.

In summary, this was a close comparison and simply came down to personal preference.

 

Pirates of the Caribbean – Disneyland vs. Disney World

 

Disneyland vs. Disney World Ride Comparisons Pirates of the Caribbean

 

Winner:  Disney World, Pirates of the Caribbean

Pirates of the Caribbean in Disneyland and Disney World share the same name; however, they are very different.

The attraction is located in Adventureland in Disney World and it is located in New Orleans Square in Disneyland.

Why is Pirates of the Caribbean better in Disney World?  

The ride queue and the theme matches.

While Disneyland’s Pirates of the Caribbean has 2 drops and is a bit longer than it’s Disney World counterpart, the first scene just doesn’t make sense.  What does a Louisiana swamp have to do with Pirates in the Caribbean?

Louisiana certainly has a rich pirate history (Jean Lafitte), but Disney’s Pirates of the Caribbean does not take place in the muddy waters of the Mississippi River delta.

My opinion may be biased because I’m a Louisiana native.

The rides are very similar other than the queue and Disneyland’s Pirates of the Caribbean stroll through the Louisiana swamp.

 

Test Track vs. Cars (Radiator Springs Racers)

Test Track vs Cars

Winner:  Disneyland, Cars (Radiator Springs Racers)

Disney World’s Test Track and Disneyland’s Radiator Springs Racers are completely different experiences, but share the same car-themed concept.

Why is Radiator Springs Racers better than Test Track?  

The overall experience is much better.  Honestly, there is really no comparison.

Most importantly, the scenery in the ride is simply awesome.  

Furthermore, the breathtaking waterfall, audio-animatronics, tire changing/new paint scene, and the big race make Radiator Spring Racers a complete experience.

Nevertheless, Test Track is a much faster ride and it may be more appealing to car racing enthusiasts.

 

Splash Mountain – Disneyland vs. Disney World

Disneyland vs. Disney World Ride Comparisons Splash Mountain

Winner:  Disney World, Splash Mountain

Splash Mountain is located in Disneyland Park in Disneyland.  Essentially, it’s Disney World counterpart is located in the Magic Kingdom.

Why is Splash Mountain better in Disney World?  

The sitting arrangement and the presentation.

Regarding comfort, the sitting arrangement in Disney World is side by side. 

Ultimately, this allows you to sit next to someone familiar.  Disneyland’s Splash Mountain is a single file seating arrangement.

In my opinion, Splash Mountain in Disney World presents the ride’s story much better & has a few more scenes.

 

Guardians of the Galaxy vs. Tower of Terror

Disneyland vs. Disney World Ride Comparisons Guardians of the Galaxy

Winner:  Disneyland, Guardians of the Galaxy

Disneyland’s Guardians of the Galaxy and Disney World’s Tower of Terror are the same ride.  Guardians of the Galaxy recently changed it’s name and theme.

Why is Guardians of the Galaxy better than Tower of Terror?  

The ride is longer and the scenery/graphics is much better.

I’m not a Guardians of the Galaxy fan.  

In fact, I haven’t seen the movie.  However, this ride inspired me to watch the movie.  It’s really that good.

Keep in mind, Tower of Terror may appeal to nostalgic Disney followers.

 

Haunted Mansion – Disneyland vs. Disney World

Disneyland vs. Disney World Ride Comparisons Haunted Mansion

Winner:  Disney World, Haunted Mansion

These attractions are the same with a few minor differences.

The Haunted Mansion in Disneyland is located in New Orleans Square.  In Disney World, it is located in Liberty Square.

In turn, the architecture is different.  

Disney World is colonial while Disneyland’s Haunted Mansion resembles a southern home.

Why is the Haunted Mansion better in Disney World?  

Simply for consistency reasons.  It is better for 9 months out of 12.

From October through the New Year, the Haunted Mansion in Disneyland gets an upgrade based on the movie “The Nightmare before Christmas.”

During this time, it is better than Disney World’s Haunted Mansion.  Disney World is better for the other 9 months of the year.

 

Big Thunder Mountain Railroad – Disneyland vs. Disney World

Disneyland vs. Disney World Ride Comparisons Thunder Mountain Waterfall

Winner:  Disneyland, Big Thunder Mountain Railroad

As you know, Big Thunder Mountain Railroad ride in Disneyland and Disney World share the same name.

Why is Big Thunder Mountain Railroad better in Disneyland?  

It’s quite simple, Disneyland’s ride received an upgrade in 2014.

In summary, Big Thunder Mountain Railroad in Disneyland is smoother and has special effects.  The line is much shorter and cooler as well.

 

Toy Story Midway Mania – Disneyland vs. Disney World

Disneyland vs. Disney World Ride Comparisons Toy Story Midway Mania

Winner:  Disney World, Toy Story Midway Mania

Again, this was a toss up.  Essentially, Toy Story Midway Mania is the same experience once on the ride.

Why is Toy Story Midway Mania better in Disney World?  

Simply because of location.

Disney World’s Toy Story Midway Mania ride is located in Hollywood Studios in the Pixar Studios area.

On the other side of the country, Disneyland’s Toy Story Midway Mania ride is located in Paradise Pier among the other boardwalk games.

Personally, I associate Pixar with Toy Story so this makes sense to me.

 

Soarin’ Around the World – Disneyland vs. Disney World

Winner:  Disney World, Soarin’

Why is Soarin’ better in Disney World?  

The location is more appealing.

If I would have answered this question before Soarin’ was renamed to Soarin’ Around the World from it’s previous name Soarin’ Over California, I would have chosen Disneyland.

Also, Soarin’ Around The World is located in Epcot and this is more fitting for a ride around the world.

Ultimately, these rides are exactly the same experience.

 

Buzz Lightyear Astro Blasters:  Disneyland vs. Disney World

Winner:  Disneyland, Buzz Lightyear Astro Blasters

Why is Buzz Lightyear Astro Blasters better in Disneyland?  

The Astro Blasters can be removed.

This ride is exactly the same; however, the Astro Blasters are attached to the ride in Disney World.

In Disneyland, they are removable, which makes blasting the space monsters easier.

 

Disneyland vs. Disney World:  Which has better rides?

Disneyland vs. Disney World Ride Comparisons Disneyland Park

So, After a 10 round fight, it is a draw:  5 – 5.

Since I have visited both Disneyland and Disney World, I do not concern myself with which has better rides.

Why? Because they are both awesome.

Nevertheless, if I find myself in Disneyland and I miss Rock ‘n’ Roller Coaster, I will stroll over to California Screamin.  The same goes for each ride comparison mentioned in this article.

 

Rides Only at Disneyland – Disneyland vs. Disney World

Here are a few rides which are only in Disneyland and not in Disney World.

 

Disneyland Park:  Snow White’s Scary Adventure

Disneyland Park:  Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride

 

Well, That’s a Wrap

Is there anything I missed?  Did I leave out important information?
 
I’d love to hear about your Disney experience, so don’t be shy!  Seriously, leave a comment and let me know your thoughts.
Affiliate links are used on this page. See my disclosure page for info on affiliate programs.
2019-04-06T22:47:34-05:0011 Comments

11 Comments

  1. KK March 26, 2018 at 11:36 pm - Reply

    INDIANA JONES!!!! Hello!!!! And space Mountain waaaaaaay better in Disney land 🦊

    • Jeremy March 27, 2018 at 6:56 am - Reply

      Definitely right about those 2 rides! We didn’t get to go on the Indiana Jones ride, but I hear it is much better in Disneyland :)

  2. Mark ES May 3, 2018 at 8:55 am - Reply

    You also are completely wrong about the Pirates of the Caribbean. First off the one at the Magic Kingdom is not in Liberty Square. It’s in Adventureland. Second, while the queue/set up of the ride in Florida is better the ride itself in California is much better. In fact, it’s almost universally considered so, even by die hard WDW fans. But I agree with most of your other picks.

    • Jeremy May 3, 2018 at 9:28 am - Reply

      Mark, thanks so much for catching my mistake! Can’t believe I said it was in Liberty Square b/c Pirates is one of my favorite rides. Thanks for taking the time to read my post and let me know about my rookie error. It is now corrected. :)

  3. Jess July 20, 2018 at 3:13 pm - Reply

    I recently became a Walt Disney World Annual Pass holder. I’m a Florida native, and have never made it out to California. I’ve been wondering a lot lately if the attractions of the same name were mostly the same in both parks or very different. I found your article very interesting and informative!

    Certainly not disputing, but only commenting, that both the Snow White ride and Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride were formally in Walt Disney World as well. Snow White(‘s Scary Adventures) has been re-themed into Peter Plan’s Flight, and Mr. Toad’s Wild Ride is now The Many Adventures of Winnie the Pooh.

    It could be nostalgia speaking, but I think I preferred both of the originals — Peter Plan’s Flight is objectively cooler in that is a ceiling suspension ride and the graphics/animatrons are much more sophisticated, but it is not scary, which was thrilling to me as a child. I cowered in the cart hiding from the Evil Witch, lol.
    The same can mostly be said of Mr. Toad’s/Winnie the Pooh, except that Pooh has remained a regular cart ride, so it doesn’t have much added wow-factor aside from graphics. But, the little ones love it, and that’s who Disney is for. Not to mention, Pooh is much more iconic than Mr. Toad.

    • Jeremy July 22, 2018 at 8:54 pm - Reply

      Hi Jess, thanks so much for commenting. I love reading other perspectives on rides bc it opens my eyes to things I don’t notice. After all, I am a guy and tend to not pay attention to little details. :)
      Thanks again and my apologies for responding late.

    • Jeremy July 22, 2018 at 8:55 pm - Reply

      Oh, forgot to mention I’m a Florida native as well. I live half the year in Destin and the other half in New Orleans.

  4. Sarah September 1, 2018 at 6:11 pm - Reply

    Matterhorn!

    • Jeremy September 6, 2018 at 3:26 pm - Reply

      Matterhorn was closed when we were there. :(

  5. Sarah January 29, 2019 at 3:36 am - Reply

    I understand how you would not like how Disneyland’s Pirates of the Caribbean starts off in Louisiana but I have a new perspective that might change your mind. POTC at Disneyland is located in New Orleans Square and we all know New Orleans is in Louisiana. This makes sense why we would start off in a Louisiana bayou. We must leave Louisiana and we do so by going down the first drop which brings us to the caves around the Caribbean. Hope this sheds new light 😊

    • Jeremy February 2, 2019 at 7:57 am - Reply

      Thank you for responding, Sarah! Makes total sense after reading your explanation. It’s even more strange because I am a New Orleans native and still live here. :)

Leave A Comment

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.

Get 25% Off!

Subscribe to Get 25% Off Any Set of Pahjo's Plans.

I won't send you spam. Unsubscribe at any time. Powered by ConvertKit